Which Transactions Does South Korea’s Subcontracting Act Cover? Lessons from a KFTC Termination of Review (Part 1)
Lessons from a KFTC Termination of Review (Part 1)
Contents
- 1. Which transactions does the Subcontracting Act cover?
- 2. What do manufacturing, repair and construction subcontracting cover?
- 3. What does service subcontracting cover?
- 4. How far do “labor services” under the Act extend?
- 5. Is work that is not on the list excluded even if it looks similar?
- 6. Which item covers moving relief crew members by vehicle?
- 7. How can you check whether your transaction is covered by the Act?
- 8. Frequently Asked Questions
Outsourcing work in South Korea does not by itself bring the Fair Transactions in Subcontracting Act into play. The Act treats only four types of entrustment as “subcontracting transactions,” and the Act and KFTC notices list what each type covers. If the work is not on those lists, the Act does not apply even if the deal looks like a subcontract.
A KFTC case that Atlas Legal handled is an example. When a vessel calls at a South Korean port, relief crew members are moved by vehicle between the airport, hotels and the pier. A transport company that had been doing this work (“Company Y”) reported a ship agency that had been arranging the work for shipowners (“Company X”) for violating the Subcontracting Act. In 2026, the KFTC closed its review on the ground that “the transaction in this case does not meet the requirements of a ‘subcontracting transaction’ under Article 2(1) of the Fair Transactions in Subcontracting Act.” The case ended with no corrective order and no administrative surcharge.
The two issues in this case
| Issue | Question | Provisions at issue | Covered in |
|---|---|---|---|
| First | Is moving relief crew members by vehicle work covered by the Act? (What was entrusted?) | Article 2(11) and (13) of the Act; the KFTC notice on labor services | This article |
| Second | Is a ship agency that arranged the work for shipowners a principal contractor under the Act? (Who entrusted it?) | Article 2(2) and (11) of the Act | Next article |
The KFTC’s letter stated only its conclusion and the provisions it relied on, so it does not say which of Company X’s two arguments it accepted. This article therefore does not describe what the KFTC found. Instead, it sets out, based on statutes and court decisions, which transactions the Act covers — the question underlying the first issue. We do not disclose the case number or the names of the parties.
Which transactions does the Subcontracting Act cover?
The Act covers four types of entrustment — manufacturing, repair, construction and service subcontracting — and the entrustment must take place between a principal contractor and a subcontractor.
The Act defines a “subcontracting transaction” as a case where “a principal contractor entrusts a subcontractor with manufacturing (including processing; the same applies hereinafter), repair, construction or services, or a principal contractor re-entrusts to a subcontractor manufacturing, repair, construction or services entrusted to it by another business,” and the subcontractor then makes the goods or performs the services, delivers them to the principal contractor and receives payment (Article 2(1)). This definition contains two requirements.
| Requirement | What it asks | Provisions |
|---|---|---|
| Transaction requirement | Is the work one of the four types of entrustment, and does it fall within what that type covers? | Article 2(1), (6), (8), (9) and (11) through (13) |
| Party requirement | Is the entrusting party a principal contractor, and the receiving party a subcontractor? | Article 2(2) and (3) |
The party requirement turns mainly on company size. A principal contractor is a business that is not a small or medium enterprise (SME) and entrusts work to an SME, or an SME whose annual sales in the preceding business year exceed those of the SME it entrusts (excluding SMEs with annual sales prescribed by Presidential Decree). A subcontractor is an SME that receives the entrustment from a principal contractor (Article 2(2) and (3)).
This article deals with the transaction requirement — “what was entrusted.” Whether the entrusting party is a principal contractor, and whether a business engaged in the work entrusted it “in the course of that business,” will be covered in the next article together with the second issue in Company X’s case.
What do manufacturing, repair and construction subcontracting cover?
Manufacturing subcontracting is a business engaged in manufacturing, selling, repairing or construction entrusting the manufacture of goods in the course of that business. Repair subcontracting entrusts the repair of goods, and construction subcontracting entrusts construction work. The KFTC’s notice determines which goods manufacturing subcontracting covers.
| Type | Entrusting party | What is entrusted | Provision |
|---|---|---|---|
| Manufacturing | A business engaged in manufacturing, selling or repairing goods, or in construction | Manufacture of goods in the course of that business (including processing) | Article 2(6) |
| Repair | A business engaged in repairing goods on order, or in repairing goods it uses itself | All or part of that repair work | Article 2(8) |
| Construction | Construction businesses, including electrical, information and communications, and fire-protection contractors | All or part of construction work in the course of that business | Article 2(9) |
For manufacturing subcontracting, the Act provides that “the scope of goods in the course of that business shall be determined and published by the Fair Trade Commission” (Article 2(6)). The resulting notice on the scope of goods subject to manufacturing subcontracting (KFTC Notice No. 2015-15) lists, for businesses engaged in manufacturing, selling or repairing goods, finished products (excluding machinery and equipment for producing them), raw materials, parts and semi-finished products ordered with specified standards or quality, molds and patterns, packaging, labels, samples and user manuals, and processing such as painting, plating, assembly and sewing. For construction businesses, it lists materials, parts and structures custom-made according to drawings or specifications (such as guardrails, signs and elevators), materials such as ready-mixed concrete and asphalt concrete ordered with specified standards or quality, and fixtures such as shoe cabinets, living room cabinets and window frames.
Buying the same part can be manufacturing subcontracting if it is custom-made to specified standards, but the notice excludes “mass-produced items simply ordered on the basis of samples or the like.” Even for a purchase of goods, whether the Act applies depends on matching “what was entrusted” against the notice’s list.
What does service subcontracting cover?
Service subcontracting covers entrusting either the preparation of knowledge or information products or the supply of labor services. The first is work that produces and delivers a deliverable; the second is work that provides labor. For both, the Act and KFTC notices set out what is covered.
The Act defines service subcontracting as a business “engaged in the preparation of knowledge or information products or the supply of labor services (services) (a service provider) entrusting all or part of its service performance in the course of that business to another service provider” (Article 2(11)).
Knowledge and information products (Article 2(12))
- Information programs — software under the Software Promotion Act, and similar items
- Films, broadcast programs and other products consisting of images, voices or sounds
- Products consisting of combinations of letters, figures or symbols, or of these combined with colors — including architectural design and design within engineering activities
- Other items comparable to items 1 through 3, as published by the KFTC
The KFTC notice on the scope of knowledge and information products in service subcontracting (KFTC Notice No. 2018-21) lists these in detail, together with the business of the entrusting party.
| Entrusting business | Covered products (examples) |
|---|---|
| Businesses engaged in preparing information programs | Software (packaged, embedded and custom, including database and website development), system-building designs, system development |
| Businesses engaged in preparing image, voice or sound products | Films and videos, games, broadcast programs, music recordings and albums, advertising production and editing, e-commerce content |
| Businesses engaged in preparing letter, figure or symbol products | Designs, trademarks, maps, compilations, design drawings |
| Businesses engaged in architectural technology, engineering, research and development | Test, inspection, analysis and evaluation reports, translations, market and opinion survey reports |
Labor services, by contrast, are activities that provide labor rather than a deliverable, and their list is narrower. For work that leaves no deliverable to hand over, such as moving relief crew members, the question is whether it counts as a labor service.
How far do “labor services” under the Act extend?
They are the four activities listed in Article 2(13) of the Act and the activities the KFTC has published under item 5 of that provision. The notice lists eight items, each in the form “a business engaged in X entrusting Y.”
“Labor services” defined by the Act (Article 2(13))
- Engineering activities under the Engineering Industry Promotion Act (excluding design)
- Transporting or arranging the transport of cargo by freight vehicle under the Trucking Transport Business Act
- Maintaining and managing buildings under the Building Act
- Security activities under the Security Services Industry Act
- Other activities of providing labor to complete work entrusted by a principal contractor, as determined and published by the KFTC
KFTC Notice on the Scope of Services in Service Subcontracting (KFTC Notice No. 2023-23, effective October 25, 2023)
| Item | Entrusting business | Entrusted activities |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Logistics | A logistics business entrusting another logistics business | Freight transport, logistics facility operation and logistics service activities; port transport and the activities of port service, goods supply, ship refueling and container repair businesses |
| 2. Sales of units | A business selling building units | Sales work |
| 3. Building management | A business engaged in maintaining and managing buildings | Cleaning, collecting, treating and hauling waste, landscape maintenance |
| 4. Software | A software business | Consulting, requirements analysis, system integration testing and installation, system operation and maintenance, data processing, hosting and the like |
| 5. Advertising | An advertising business | Promotion, events, research and filming; editing, developing and recording; planning exhibitions and events, and the like |
| 6. Performances | A business engaged in performances or performance planning | Editing, developing, recording, filming, sound, lighting, art and the like |
| 7. Surveying | A business engaged in architectural design, engineering design, surveying and the like | Surveying, geological investigation and exploration, and the like |
| 8. Re-entrustment | A business entrusted with the services above | All or part of the entrusted services |
Each item names both the entrusting party’s business and the entrusted activity. The logistics item, for example, applies only where a logistics business entrusts another logistics business. The same activity can fall inside or outside the notice depending on who entrusts it to whom.
Conversely, if a deal is a subcontracting transaction, the Act’s protections — such as direct payment of subcontract fees by the ordering party — become available.
Is work that is not on the list excluded even if it looks similar?
The Supreme Court of Korea held that work that is not a labor service under the KFTC notice is not service subcontracting under the Act, so the KFTC cannot issue a corrective order or impose an administrative surcharge on that basis. The Court did not extend the list to cover similar work.
The Court first stated that “administrative regulations that form the basis of an adverse administrative disposition must be interpreted and applied strictly, and must not be interpreted expansively or by analogy to the detriment of the person subject to the disposition,” and that even a purposive interpretation “must not depart from the ordinary meaning of the text” (Supreme Court of Korea, September 30, 2016, 2015Du53961; Supreme Court of Korea, February 28, 2008, 2007Du13791, 13807).
In that case, the KFTC had issued a corrective order and a surcharge on grounds including that a business entrusted software maintenance without issuing the required written contract. The notice then in force listed system operation and maintenance by computer-related service businesses as labor services, but with the proviso: “provided that ‘information programs’ under Article 2(12)(i) of the Subcontracting Act are excluded.” Applying this proviso, the Court held that software maintenance “cannot be regarded as the supply of ‘labor services’ as defined in the notice provision in this case, and therefore does not constitute ‘service subcontracting’ under the Subcontracting Act,” and that even if the written contract had not been issued, “no corrective order or administrative surcharge can be imposed under the Subcontracting Act on that ground.” It dismissed the KFTC’s appeal, adding that the KFTC bears the burden of proving that its disposition was lawful (Supreme Court of Korea, September 30, 2016, 2015Du53961).
The notice applied in that judgment was the version before its amendment on December 23, 2014. Section I.4(a) of the current notice (No. 2023-23) states that it includes the operation and maintenance of information programs, so a deal entrusting software maintenance today may come out differently. What this judgment teaches is less its conclusion about software than the principle that the wording of the Act and the notice in force at the time of the transaction determines what the Act covers.
A court judgment also records the KFTC closing a case on the same ground. In a dispute over installing and test-running an optical measuring device, the KFTC closed its review in 2020 because “the installation and test run do not fall within the scope of labor services listed in the notice on the scope of services in service subcontracting and do not constitute service subcontracting, so the transaction between the plaintiff and the defendant does not meet the requirements of a subcontracting transaction under the Act.” In the later suit over the service fee, the court also found the evidence insufficient to show a subcontract, so it ordered payment of the fee but did not apply the 15.5% annual late-payment interest rate under the Subcontracting Act (Seoul Southern District Court, January 13, 2022, 2021Na54116).
Transport carries the same label in many contexts, but it must still fit the transport the notice describes. Regarding a contract to carry a drilling platform by sea, the Busan District Court held that the contract “is a maritime transport contract and does not concern port transport, so it cannot be regarded as a subcontract under the Subcontracting Act” (Busan District Court, October 23, 2024, 2023Gahap46780). The appellate court reached the same result for a different reason — the company that performed the transport was not an SME covered by the Act — and dismissed the appeal (Busan High Court, August 21, 2025, 2024Na57661).
Which item covers moving relief crew members by vehicle?
Nothing in the wording of the Act or the notice fits this work. The freight vehicle item covers “cargo,” the logistics item covers “goods,” and the only item that covers carrying people is limited to doing so “by launch boat” between a ship and the shore.
In Company X’s case, most of Company Y’s work consisted of moving relief crew members by vehicle between airports, hotels and vessels, with some delivery of ship’s stores or parts designated by the shipowner. In its written opinions, Company X matched this work against each item in the Act and the notice.
Freight transport (Article 2(13)(ii)) — The Trucking Transport Business Act defines a freight vehicle transport business as “a business of transporting cargo for a fee using freight vehicles at the request of others” (Article 2(iii)). Carrying people by motor vehicle for a fee is separately defined as a passenger transport business under the Passenger Transport Service Act (Article 2(iii)), and that business is not among the activities listed in Article 2(13) of the Subcontracting Act.
Logistics business (Section I.1(a) of the notice) — The Framework Act on Logistics Policies, to which the notice refers, defines logistics as “the transport, storage, loading and unloading, etc. of goods from the time they are procured or produced by a supplier until they are delivered to a consumer, or recovered from a consumer and disposed of,” and a logistics business as one that “carries on logistics activities for a fee at the request of shippers” (Article 2(1)(i) and (ii)). Relief crew members are not goods.
Port services (Section I.1(b) of the notice) — The item that covers carrying people is the port service activity of “carrying people or documents between a ship and the shore by launch boat” (Article 2(1)(a) of the Enforcement Decree of the Port Transport Business Act). That activity is carried out by boat, so moving people by vehicle between airports, hotels and piers falls outside its wording.
Whether the Act applies does not turn on the transport taking place on land. If cargo had been moved by freight vehicle, that would have been a labor service under item 2. The point is that what was transported was people, not cargo, and none of the listed items covers that.
Whether each type of work is a listed labor service (based on the statutory wording)
| Work | Relevant provision | Listed labor service? |
|---|---|---|
| Cargo transport by freight vehicle | Article 2(13)(ii) of the Act | Yes |
| Carrying people or documents by launch boat | Article 2(1)(a) of the Enforcement Decree of the Port Transport Business Act; Section I.1(b) of the notice | Possibly |
| Supplying ship’s stores | Article 2(2) of the same Enforcement Decree; Section I.1(b) of the notice | Possibly |
| Moving crew members by vehicle | No corresponding item | No item in the wording |
On the delivery of ship’s stores and parts, Company X acknowledged up front in its written opinion that there was room to argue that it was a labor service, while explaining that this work was a small share and that the transactions underlying the report were crew transport. Section I.1(b) of the notice uses the term “goods supply business,” while the current Enforcement Decree of the Port Transport Business Act calls the business of supplying ships with beverages, food, consumables, spare parts for repairs and other ship’s stores a “ship’s stores supply business” (Article 2(2)). Because the terms differ, the actual work needs to be examined.
The KFTC closed this case on the ground that the requirements of a subcontracting transaction were not met. Because the letter did not break down its reasons, however, it cannot be said whether that conclusion rested on the first issue or the second.
How can you check whether your transaction is covered by the Act?
The starting point is to match the entrusted work against the lists in the Act and the notices, item by item. The following order can be used.
- Which of the four types does it fall under? — whether you had goods made (manufacturing), repaired (repair), construction work done (construction), or a deliverable produced or labor provided (services)
- If it is a service, is it a deliverable or labor? — work that produces and hands over a deliverable is a knowledge or information product; work that provides labor is a labor service
- Which item in Article 2(13) or the notice does it fit? — whether there is an item that fits the wording, not merely a similar one, and whether the entrusting party’s business and the receiving party also match what the notice describes
- Which version of the notice applied at the time? — notices are amended; software maintenance, which was excluded from the notice applied in the Supreme Court judgment, is included in the current notice
- Who entrusted it to whom? — whether the entrusting party carries on that work as its business and whether the size requirements for principal contractors and subcontractors are met (next article)
Even where the Subcontracting Act does not apply, whether cutting off business or forcing terms is an unfair trade practice under the Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trade Act is a separate question. We discussed that standard in “Abuse of Superior Bargaining Position in South Korea.”
Frequently Asked Questions
Q. If the Subcontracting Act does not apply, does the company that performed the work lose all protection?
A. It loses the protections that exist only under the Subcontracting Act, but it can still claim payment under its contract. In a case where the KFTC had closed its review because the transaction was not a subcontracting transaction, the court in the later suit over service fees ordered payment of the KRW 17 million fee but refused to apply the 15.5% annual late-payment interest rate available under the Subcontracting Act (Seoul Southern District Court, January 13, 2022, 2021Na54116). As for direct payment of subcontract fees by the ordering party, a court held that the Act “specifically sets out the requirements for principal contractors and subcontractors and thereby limits its scope,” so the same rules cannot be applied merely because the subcontractor needs protection (Busan High Court, August 21, 2025, 2024Na57661).
Q. Would the answer change if crew members were moved by launch boat instead of by vehicle?
A. It could. Carrying people or documents between a ship and the shore by launch boat is a port service business (Article 2(1)(a) of the Enforcement Decree of the Port Transport Business Act), and the KFTC notice lists the activities of port service businesses as covered services (Section I.1(b) of the notice). Section I.1, however, covers cases where a business engaged in the logistics business entrusts another logistics business with those activities, so who entrusted what to whom must also be examined. In Company X’s case, it showed with documents that the launch boats were operated by a launch boat operator and that the shipowner paid the launch fees.
Q. If the contract says the parties will comply with the Subcontracting Act, does the Act apply?
A. Not on that basis alone. Faced with an argument that the contract contained a clause on complying with the Subcontracting Act and that both parties treated the deal as a subcontracting transaction, the Patent Court of Korea held that “whether the former Subcontracting Act applies to the transaction between the plaintiff and the defendant is a question of applying the law, so the provisions of the Act cannot be regarded as applying to the contract merely on the subjective ground that both parties believed the Act applied,” and the Supreme Court of Korea dismissed the appeal (Patent Court of Korea, September 6, 2019, 2018Na1305; Supreme Court of Korea, June 1, 2023, 2019Da270750).
Q. Who has to prove that the Subcontracting Act applies?
A. When the KFTC imposes a corrective order or an administrative surcharge and the business challenges it in court, the KFTC bears the burden. The Supreme Court of Korea stated that “in an action for revocation, the defendant asserting the legality of the disposition bears the burden of proving the grounds for its legality” and dismissed the KFTC’s appeal (Supreme Court of Korea, September 30, 2016, 2015Du53961). In a civil case, a claim for late-payment interest at the rate under the Subcontracting Act failed because the evidence was insufficient to show that the contract was a subcontract (Seoul Southern District Court, January 13, 2022, 2021Na54116).
Q. Is a KFTC “termination of review” the same as a no-violation finding?
A. No. Under the Rules on the Operation of KFTC Meetings and Case Handling Procedures, a case examiner may, on his or her own authority, terminate the review of a case falling under Article 53 and make a no-violation finding in a case falling under Article 54 (Article 61(1)). A no-violation finding applies where the respondent’s conduct “is not found to be a violation, or there is no evidence of a violation” of the Subcontracting Act or other laws (Article 54(1)). Item 1 of Article 53 incorporates item 17 of Article 20(1), which is the case where “the requirements of a ‘subcontracting transaction,’ ‘principal contractor’ or ‘subcontractor’ under Article 2(1) through (3) of the Subcontracting Act are not met.” The reason given in Company X’s letter tracks that wording.
Q. We are a foreign company that outsources work in South Korea. What should we check first?
A. Start with what you actually entrust and match it against the lists in the Act and the KFTC notices. Under South Korean law, moving goods by truck, carrying people by launch boat and supplying ship’s stores can be covered services, while moving people by vehicle does not appear in the statutory list. Check the version of the notice in force at the time of the transaction, because the notices are amended. Our firm advises foreign companies, including those in the Incheon Free Economic Zone (IFEZ) — Songdo International Business District, Cheongna International City and Yeongjong International City.
This article is based on a case our firm handled and on published court judgments and statutes, and is not legal advice for any particular case. Quotations from Korean judgments, statutes, KFTC notices and the KFTC’s letter are our English translations. The KFTC’s termination of review rested on the facts of that case, and lower court judgments may be changed on appeal. In the next article, we will look at the second issue in this case: whether a ship agency that arranged work for shipowners is a principal contractor under the Act. For our services to foreign companies, see our IFEZ page. If you need to know whether a transaction in South Korea falls under the Subcontracting Act, please consult Atlas Legal.
