Is a Research Allowance a Wage in South Korea? Supreme Court Decision 2023Da311733 on National R&D Projects
Why the Supreme Court Reversed the Lower Court That Treated Them as Wages
Contents
- 1. What was the case about?
- 2. How do Korean courts decide whether a payment is a wage?
- 3. Why is a research allowance not ‘consideration for work’?
- 4. Does an institute’s payment standard create an obligation to pay?
- 5. Did years of payment create a binding labor practice?
- 6. How does this compare with the 2026 bonus decision?
- 7. What should research institutes and researchers in South Korea check?
- 8. Frequently asked questions
From 2016 to 2018, the participating researchers on South Korea’s Phase 1 lunar exploration development project received a share of the research allowances. When reviews of the project began around late 2018, however, the research allowances for January to May 2019 were left out of the project agreement. The researchers claimed those allowances, and the lower court held that they were wages and that, since the researchers had continued to work on the project during that period, the institute was obliged to pay them.
The Supreme Court of Korea reached a different conclusion. On November 12, 2026, it held that the research allowances are hard to regard as money paid as consideration for work or as wages that the employer is obliged to pay, and it reversed and remanded the case (Supreme Court of Korea, November 12, 2026, 2023Da311733). Researchers taking part in Korean national R&D projects can receive research allowances out of R&D expenses whatever their institution, so the decision touches the allowance structure of research workplaces across South Korea.
This article explains the test and the reasons based on the judgment summary published by the Supreme Court, together with related judgments and statutes. The full text of the judgment had not been published as of November 17, 2026, when this article was written, so details such as the lower court and the amounts claimed are not covered.
What was the case about?
The dispute began when the research allowances for January to May 2019 were left out of the project agreement. The researchers claimed them as wages; the lower court agreed, but the Supreme Court did not.
In 2016 the Minister of Science and ICT (then the Minister of Science, ICT and Future Planning) selected the defendant, a government-funded research institute, as the lead research institution for Phase 1 of the lunar exploration development project. The defendant entered into a standard R&D project agreement with the National Research Foundation of Korea, which had been entrusted with the related work, and each year the Foundation paid government contributions to the defendant as R&D expenses under the agreement for that year. From 2016 to 2018 the defendant distributed the research allowances it received from the Foundation to the participating researchers, including the plaintiffs.
From around late 2018 to mid-2019, however, the defendant’s internal review and reviews by outside bodies looked into the project’s problems and whether it should continue. On the ground that research toward the project’s goals had in effect stopped while the reviews were under way, the defendant concluded the 2019 standard agreement with the Foundation so that it covered research allowances only for the rest of the year, leaving out January to May 2019. As a result, those five months of research allowances were not budgeted as R&D expenses under the agreement.
| Issue | Lower court | Supreme Court |
|---|---|---|
| Nature of the allowance | Wages paid continuously and regularly as consideration for work | Hard to regard as money paid as consideration for work |
| Obligation to pay | Obligation under the relevant rules or the defendant’s labor practice | No basis found in the payment standard, pay regulations, statutes, labor practice or the agreement |
| Unbudgeted period | The plaintiffs worked on the project during that period, so the allowances or an equivalent amount must be paid | Neither an obligation to pay nor consideration for work is recognized |
| Result | Obligation to pay recognized | Reversed and remanded |
The Supreme Court examined in turn whether the defendant was obliged to pay the research allowances and whether they were consideration for work. The sections below take the test and the reasons one by one.
How do Korean courts decide whether a payment is a wage?
Under Korean law a payment is a wage only if it is consideration for work, is paid continuously and regularly, and is something the employer is obliged to pay. Whether it is consideration for work comes first.
Article 2(1)5 of the Labor Standards Act defines wages as “all money and valuables paid by an employer to a worker as consideration for work, whether called wages, salary or by any other name.” In this case the Supreme Court stated that “wages are money and valuables paid by an employer to a worker as consideration for work, which are paid to the worker continuously and regularly and which the employer is obliged to pay under a collective agreement, rules of employment, pay regulations, an employment contract, labor practice or the like” (Supreme Court of Korea, November 12, 2026, 2023Da311733).
The Court added that even a payment made continuously and regularly is not a wage if it cannot be regarded as paid as consideration for work. Whether it is consideration for work is decided by asking whether “the arising of the obligation to pay the money can be regarded as directly or closely related to the provision of work” (Supreme Court of Korea, November 12, 2026, 2023Da311733). The Court used the same test in its bonus decision of January 29, 2026 (Supreme Court of Korea, January 29, 2026, 2022Da255454).
| Requirement | Meaning | This case |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Consideration for work | The obligation to pay arises in direct or close relation to the provision of work | Not recognized |
| 2. Continuous and regular payment | Paid repeatedly at regular intervals | Not separately addressed in the published summary |
| 3. Obligation to pay | The employer cannot decide at its discretion whether to pay | Not recognized |
The starting point of the decision is that being paid year after year does not by itself make money a wage. Even if the money looks the same to the person receiving it, the court looks separately at what gives rise to the obligation to pay it.
Why is a research allowance not ‘consideration for work’?
The Supreme Court gave three reasons: the rules treat research allowances as rewards and incentives distinct from personnel expenses, paying them as a fixed monthly amount like salary is improper spending to be recovered, and whether they are paid can depend on project budgeting and on recovery by the government.
Rewards and incentives distinct from personnel expenses
The Court found that the relevant statutes, the defendant’s rules of employment and its payment standard regulate research allowances as allowances for paying rewards and incentives to the principal investigator and participating researchers, distinct from personnel expenses (Supreme Court of Korea, November 12, 2026, 2023Da311733).
Appendix 2 to the Regulations on the Management, etc. of National Research and Development Projects (a Presidential Decree) in force at the time set out personnel expenses and research allowances as separate items within the direct costs of R&D expenses. The use of research allowances was defined as “allowances for paying rewards and incentives to the principal investigator and participating researchers in connection with carrying out the R&D task,” to be budgeted within 20 percent of personnel expenses and certain related amounts. Note 4 to the same Appendix required the head of the research institution and the principal investigator to adopt reasonable standards, such as an evaluation of contribution, and to pay research allowances in accordance with them.
Fixed monthly payments are improper spending
The Court also relied on the fact that the relevant rules treat paying research allowances as a fixed monthly amount, like salary, as improper spending to be recovered (Supreme Court of Korea, November 12, 2026, 2023Da311733). The published summary does not name the provision, but Appendix 8 to the Regulations on the Handling of Science and Technology R&D Projects under the Ministry of Science and ICT, a ministerial directive in force at the time, listed “where research allowances are paid as a fixed amount every month” among the criteria for recovering improperly spent research allowances. In other words, paying the same amount every month like salary was itself not permitted.
Payment depends on the budget and on recovery
Finally, the Court found that whether research allowances are paid can depend on whether they are included in the project budget, or on recovery by the head of the central administrative agency, matters unrelated to both the workers and the employer (Supreme Court of Korea, November 12, 2026, 2023Da311733). Put simply, this can be read to mean that even if researchers do the same work, there is nothing to pay them if no research allowance is budgeted in the agreement, and money paid can later be recovered. For these reasons the Court concluded that research allowances cannot be regarded as directly or closely related to the provision of work.
Does an institute’s payment standard create an obligation to pay?
The Supreme Court found that the payment standard in this case did not by itself create an obligation to pay research allowances that were not budgeted, because the defendant’s standard merely set out how to distribute the research allowances budgeted for a project.
An employer is obliged to pay when it cannot decide at its discretion whether to pay. That obligation may arise from a collective agreement, rules of employment, pay regulations or an employment contract, or from labor practice (Supreme Court of Korea, May 28, 1997, 96Nu15084; Supreme Court of Korea, November 12, 2026, 2023Da311733).
In this case the defendant’s payment standard provided for distributing the research allowances budgeted for a project among the participating researchers after evaluating them in accordance with the relevant rules. The Court found that such a standard could hardly serve as the basis for an obligation to pay research allowances that were not budgeted for the project. The pay regulations, which set out matters concerning pay in accordance with the employment contracts, the collective agreement and the rules of employment, contained no provision on research allowances, and the relevant statutes merely set the standards for budgeting R&D expenses and did not ground an obligation to pay research allowances (Supreme Court of Korea, November 12, 2026, 2023Da311733).
In short, the Court found that the payment standard decided who would get how much of the research allowances that had been budgeted; it was not a promise to pay research allowances whether or not they were budgeted.
Did years of payment create a binding labor practice?
The fact that research allowances had been paid for several years did not establish a labor practice. The Supreme Court pointed out that on projects where research allowances were not budgeted, or only partly budgeted, they were paid only within the budgeted amount, and the participating researchers raised no objection.
For a practice within a company to form part of the employment contract, the practice must be “explicitly accepted as a normative fact generally governing employment relationships in the business community, or generally accepted as a matter of course by the members of the company without objection, so that it is supported by a normative consciousness to the extent that it can be said to be established as a de facto system within the company” (Supreme Court of Korea, April 23, 2002, 2000Da50701). The Supreme Court relied on the same principle in this case (Supreme Court of Korea, November 12, 2026, 2023Da311733).
What the published summary shows is that research allowances were paid only to the extent budgeted and that the participating researchers raised no objection. In light of this, the Court held that no obligation to pay arose from labor practice either. It added that, since the 2019 standard agreement that did not budget the research allowances had been validly concluded, there was no obligation to pay under the agreement either (Supreme Court of Korea, November 12, 2026, 2023Da311733).
How does this compare with the 2026 bonus decision?
The Court used the same test and reached the same result. On January 29, 2026, it held that a guarantee insurance company’s special performance bonus was not part of the wages used to calculate average wages, and in both decisions the factor deciding whether the money was paid lay outside the provision of work.
In that case the special performance bonus was paid from 2006 to 2020 under annual labor-management agreements and was calculated according to the rate at which management performance targets agreed with the labor union were achieved; from the 2007 agreement onward, “realizing net profit” was expressly made a condition of payment. The Court denied that it was a wage on two grounds. First, because the rules of employment reserved to the employer the discretion over whether and on what basis to pay bonuses, and the payment criteria were fixed by labor-management agreement every year, it was hard to say that labor practice obliged the company to pay every year. Second, because the net profit of a guarantee insurance company results from the combination of the workers’ work with other factors such as the size of equity or borrowed capital, the size of expenses, market conditions and management decisions, the bonus was in the nature of distributing management results to the workers rather than consideration for work (Supreme Court of Korea, January 29, 2026, 2022Da255454).
| Issue | Special performance bonus (2022Da255454) | Research allowance (2023Da311733) |
|---|---|---|
| What decided payment | Whether the company made a net profit | Whether the allowance was in the project budget; recovery by the central administrative agency |
| Obligation to pay | Discretion reserved in the rules of employment; criteria set by annual labor-management agreement, so no labor practice | Payment standard only distributed budgeted amounts; nothing in the pay regulations; paid only within the budget without objection, so no labor practice |
| Nature | Distribution of management results | Rewards and incentives distinct from personnel expenses |
| Result | Not wages for calculating average wages; the part the defendant lost reversed and remanded | Hard to regard as wages; reversed and remanded |
The difference lies in where the money comes from. A bonus is money a company uses to share its profits, whereas a research allowance under a national R&D project is an item of R&D expenses budgeted under the project agreement, so its budgeting and spending are tied to statutes and agreements. In this case the R&D expenses were paid out of government contributions. The bonus decisions handed down on January 29, 2026 are covered separately in “Are Performance Bonuses Included in Severance Pay in South Korea? 2026 Supreme Court Ruling Explained.”
What should research institutes and researchers in South Korea check?
Taken together, the reasons the Court gave mean that a research allowance is an incentive received after evaluation, within the amount budgeted in the agreement. Researchers and institutes alike should treat research allowances as money managed separately from salary.
For researchers
- Check whether research allowances are budgeted in the agreement. This case concerned allowances that were not budgeted, and the Court denied both an obligation to pay and their character as consideration for work.
- Check whether your institute’s pay regulations, collective agreement or employment contract separately provide for payment of research allowances. In this case the Court relied on the absence of any such provision as one reason for denying an obligation to pay. If there is such a provision, a claim under it may be considered, but that alone does not make the allowance a wage.
- Check how an agreement that leaves out research allowances came to be concluded. The Court held that, since the 2019 standard agreement had been validly concluded, there was no obligation to pay under the agreement.
For research institutes
- Frame the payment standard for research allowances as a method of distributing the budgeted research allowances according to an evaluation of contribution or similar criteria. Article 26(5) of the current Standards for the Use of R&D Expenses for National R&D Projects (a Ministry of Science and ICT notice) likewise requires the head of an R&D institution to adopt reasonable standards for paying research allowances, such as an evaluation of the contribution of all participating researchers, and to pay in accordance with them.
- Keep the pay regulations and the payment standard for research allowances separate. Article 39(3) of the current notice, in defining the annual salary of participating researchers at government-funded institutions, likewise excludes research allowances (the monthly salary of researchers at universities and for-profit institutions is defined the same way, Articles 48(3) and 65(3)).
- When reducing or removing research allowances in an agreement, keep a record of the reasons and the procedure. In this case, too, whether the agreement had been validly concluded formed part of the Court’s reasoning.
For foreign-invested companies with R&D centers in South Korea
Foreign-invested companies that run research centers in the Incheon Free Economic Zone (IFEZ), including the Songdo International Business District, Cheongna International City and Yeongjong International City, and take part in Korean national R&D projects should keep the same distinction in mind. When drafting employment contracts and pay regulations for researchers, decide deliberately whether research allowances funded from a national R&D project are to be described as part of pay, because the Court treated the absence of such a provision as one reason for denying an obligation to pay.
The current Enforcement Decree of the National Research and Development Innovation Act, in its Appendix 2, also defines research allowances as “incentives paid to the principal investigator and researchers (including student researchers) taking part in carrying out an R&D task.” This case applied the rules in force in 2019, but the framework that treats research allowances as incentives distinct from personnel expenses continues under the current system.
Frequently asked questions
Q. If my research allowance was not paid, can I treat it as unpaid wages?
A. Under the test in this decision, that is difficult. The Supreme Court of Korea held that the research allowances in this case are hard to regard as money paid as consideration for work or as wages that the employer is obliged to pay (Supreme Court of Korea, November 12, 2026, 2023Da311733). If your institute’s pay regulations or collective agreement separately provide for payment of research allowances, a claim under those provisions may be considered, but that alone does not make the allowance a wage.
Q. I kept doing the research work. Am I still not entitled to the allowance?
A. The lower court in this case recognized an obligation to pay because the researchers had continued to work on the project during the period for which no research allowance was budgeted, but the Supreme Court reversed that decision. Its reason was that whether research allowances are paid can depend on whether they are included in the project budget or on recovery by the head of the central administrative agency, so they cannot be regarded as directly or closely related to the provision of work, among other things; the Court also found no obligation to pay (Supreme Court of Korea, November 12, 2026, 2023Da311733).
Q. Would the outcome differ if the allowance had been paid every month without fail?
A. Being paid continuously and regularly does not by itself make a payment a wage. The Supreme Court held that even a payment made continuously and regularly is not a wage if it cannot be regarded as paid as consideration for work (Supreme Court of Korea, November 12, 2026, 2023Da311733). The Court also relied on the fact that the relevant rules treat paying research allowances as a fixed monthly amount, like salary, as improper spending to be recovered.
Q. Is anything called a ‘research allowance’ always outside the scope of wages?
A. No, the label does not decide the question. Article 2(1)5 of the Labor Standards Act treats as wages any money paid as consideration for work under whatever name. The Supreme Court has upheld, for example, a lower court’s conclusion that duty allowances, research allowances and other payments that a hospital made to its medical residents were ordinary wages (Supreme Court of Korea, September 11, 2025, 2019Da273803). The research allowances in this case were found not to be wages because, among other things, they are rewards and incentives distinct from personnel expenses and their payment can depend on budgeting and recovery.
Q. Does the same reasoning apply to researchers at corporate research centers or universities?
A. This decision concerned a government-funded research institute. The legal character of research allowances on which the Court relied is, however, defined in the same way regardless of the type of R&D institution. Article 11 of the current Standards for the Use of R&D Expenses for National R&D Projects also defines research allowances as incentives paid to the principal investigator and researchers taking part in an R&D task. If an institution has separately promised research allowances in its own rules, a claim under that promise may be considered, but that alone does not make them wages.
Q. What happens to a case after it is reversed and remanded?
A. The case goes back to the lower court, which hears the parties again and gives a new judgment. The court on remand is bound by the factual and legal findings on which the Supreme Court based the reversal (Article 436(2) of the Civil Procedure Act). In this case, the lower court will reconsider the claims on the premise that the research allowances are hard to regard as wages.
This article summarizes the judgment summary published by the Supreme Court of Korea for its decision of November 12, 2026, together with related judgments and statutes, and is not legal advice for any particular case. Because the full text of the judgment has not yet been published, the explanation stays within the published summary. Quotations from Korean judgments and statutes are our English translations. If you need to assess whether a research allowance or a bonus counts as a wage in South Korea, consider consulting Atlas Legal.
