Enforcement Against Crypto-Assets in South Korea: What the Amended Civil Execution Rules Changed About Attachment and Realization
What the Amended Civil Execution Rules Changed About Attachment and Realization
Contents
- 1. What changed in enforcement against crypto-assets?
- 2. What is attached now?
- 3. What changes when an exchange receives an attachment order?
- 4. How are attached crypto-assets turned into money?
- 5. By what methods does an execution officer sell crypto-assets?
- 6. Can crypto-assets held in a private wallet be attached?
- 7. Can a debtor be stopped from moving the assets away before judgment?
- 8. Frequently asked questions
In Can Bitcoin Be Attached? Enforcement Against Crypto-Assets in South Korea we explained that crypto-assets left with an exchange can be attached. At that time, however, there were no execution provisions written for crypto-assets, so the provisions on enforcement against other property rights had to be borrowed, and there was no provision setting out how attached crypto-assets were to be turned into money.
That gap has now been filled. The Civil Execution Rules, which are Supreme Court Rules, were amended on October 12, 2026 (Supreme Court Rules No. 3280) and have been in force since November 1, 2026. What is attached in the hands of an exchange, what the exchange has to disclose, who sells attached crypto-assets and by what method, and what happens to crypto-assets held in a private wallet are now all set out in the Rules.
This article follows the provisions of the amended Rules and sets out what has changed. Because the new provisions entered into force only recently, we have not found a judgment or decision applying them (as of November 10, 2026). Court practice may become more concrete over time.
What changed in enforcement against crypto-assets?
The largest change is that there are now execution provisions written for crypto-assets. Twelve new Articles, 175-2 to 175-13, were added to the Civil Execution Rules, together with provisions on the enforcement of security rights (Article 200-2), provisional attachment (Article 213-2) and provisional disposition (Article 216-2).
Before the amendment there was no execution provision dealing with crypto-assets directly. The approach taken was to treat a right that a debtor held against an exchange as one of the “other property rights” under Article 251(1) of the Civil Execution Act and to apply the provisions on enforcement against claims mutatis mutandis. There was no provision tailored to crypto-assets for turning an attached asset into money either.
That crypto-assets can be treated as property was confirmed first in case law. In a case about the confiscation of Bitcoin obtained through crime, the Supreme Court of Korea said that “Bitcoin is a kind of so-called ‘virtual currency,’ which digitally represents economic value and is made capable of being transferred, stored and traded electronically,” and treated that Bitcoin as “intangible property having proprietary value” (Supreme Court of Korea, May 30, 2018, 2018Do3619). That was a criminal confiscation case, so it is not a judgment that settled the civil execution procedure. The amendment is precisely what settles that procedure.
Before and after the amendment
| Item | Before | After (from November 1, 2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Basis | Applied mutatis mutandis through Article 251(1) of the Civil Execution Act (other property rights) | Articles 175-2 to 175-13 of the Civil Execution Rules |
| Crypto-assets held at an exchange | Attachment of a claim against the exchange for withdrawal (return) | Attachment of a claim for the transfer of crypto-assets (Articles 175-2 and 175-3) |
| Statement by the exchange | The general items under Article 237 of the Civil Execution Act | Whether the exchange holds crypto-assets corresponding to the claim, and their kind and quantity (Article 175-4) |
| Realization | No provision written for crypto-assets | Transfer order and sale order (Article 175-5); four methods of sale (Article 175-6) |
| Crypto-assets in a private wallet | No provision | Attachment of the crypto-assets themselves and an order to transfer them to an execution officer (Articles 175-7 and 175-8) |
| Provisional attachment and disposition | No provision written for crypto-assets | Articles 213-2 and 216-2 |
| Pending cases | — | The amended Rules apply (Article 2 of the Addenda) |
What is attached now?
The Rules divide the subject of attachment into two branches. If the debtor has left crypto-assets with a third party such as an exchange, what is attached is the claim against that third party for the transfer of the crypto-assets (Article 175-2); if the debtor holds them directly, the crypto-assets themselves are attached (Article 175-7).
Crypto-assets here are the crypto-assets defined in Article 2(1)1 of the Act on the Protection of Virtual Asset Users (Article 175-2). That Act defines a crypto-asset as “an electronic token (including any and all rights relating thereto) that has economic value and can be traded or transferred electronically,” while excluding the items listed in the proviso to the same subparagraph, such as electronic currency and electronically registered shares. The Supreme Court of Korea has also treated Bitcoin as a kind of crypto-asset within that definition (Supreme Court of Korea, December 11, 2025, 2025Mo45).
The Rules address the situation in which a debtor holds a claim for the transfer of crypto-assets against a third party such as an exchange, and make that claim the subject of attachment (Article 175-2). There is a judgment on how crypto-assets left with an exchange are managed. In a case concerning the operating structure of an overseas crypto-asset exchange, the Seoul Northern District Court found that, when a user transfers crypto-assets into that exchange’s wallet, it appears to be “a structure in which the authority to manage or own the actual crypto-assets passes to the plaintiff, which operates the exchange, and the user merely acquires against the plaintiff a claim for the return of crypto-assets.” The actual crypto-assets move only between the omnibus account managed by the exchange and external accounts, while the user’s account shows no more than a book balance (Seoul Northern District Court, February 12, 2026, 2024Gahap22393, 2025Gahap20759). That was a first-instance finding of fact about how one particular exchange operated, so it cannot be generalized to say that every exchange is structured in the same way.
What the previous article called a “claim for withdrawal” is called a “claim for the transfer of crypto-assets” in the Rules. The Rules state expressly that a garnishee served with an attachment order includes a virtual asset service provider as defined in Article 2(1)2 of the Act on the Protection of Virtual Asset Users (Article 175-3).
The two branches compared
| Item | Crypto-assets held at an exchange | Crypto-assets held by the debtor directly |
|---|---|---|
| Subject of attachment | Claim for the transfer of crypto-assets | The crypto-assets themselves |
| Basis | Articles 175-2 to 175-6 | Articles 175-7 to 175-11 |
| Prohibitions and orders | Exchange: must not transfer to the debtor Debtor: must not dispose of the claim or take a transfer |
Debtor: must not dispose of the assets, and is ordered to transfer them to an execution officer |
| Realization | Transfer order or sale order of the claim for the transfer of crypto-assets | Transfer order or sale order of the crypto-assets |
What changes when an exchange receives an attachment order?
An exchange served with an attachment order must not transfer the crypto-assets to the debtor, and the debtor must not dispose of the claim or take a transfer of the crypto-assets (Article 175-3). The creditor may apply to the court for an order requiring the exchange to state in writing, within one week, whether it actually holds crypto-assets corresponding to the attached claim and their kind and quantity (Article 175-4).
The attachment order is served on the exchange and on the debtor, and the attachment takes effect when it is served on the exchange (Article 175-13(1) of the Rules and Article 227(2) and (3) of the Civil Execution Act). An attachment must be made within the limits needed for the amount claimed in the authentic copy with executory power and the costs of execution, so it cannot extend beyond that scope (Article 175-13(1) of the Rules and Article 188(2) of the Civil Execution Act).
What the exchange must state (Article 175-4)
- Whether it acknowledges the claim for the transfer of crypto-assets and, if so, its content
- Whether the exchange holds crypto-assets corresponding to that claim and, if so, their kind and quantity
- Whether there is a person with a right ranking ahead of the attaching creditor and, if so, who that person is, the kind of right, and the extent to which it ranks ahead
- Whether there is an attachment, provisional attachment or provisional disposition by another creditor and, if so, the case, the creditor, the date of service and the scope of execution
The second item matters most. It does not appear among the items to be stated under Article 237 of the Civil Execution Act for monetary claims, and it becomes the route for confirming whether the exchange actually holds crypto-assets matching the attached claim, and of what kind and in what quantity. If the exchange neglects to make the statement, the court may interrogate the exchange (Article 175-13(1) of the Rules and Article 237(3) of the Civil Execution Act).
How are attached crypto-assets turned into money?
On the creditor’s application, the court may issue a “transfer order” passing the attached claim for the transfer of crypto-assets to the creditor at a value fixed by the court, or a “sale order” having an execution officer sell it, or may order realization by another appropriate method (Article 175-5(1)). That ruling may be challenged by immediate appeal, and takes effect only once it becomes final (paragraphs (2) and (3) of the same Article).
The previous article described an approach of applying Article 243 of the Civil Execution Act on claims for delivery of corporeal movables by analogy, having the assets delivered to an execution officer and then selling them through the special method of realization under Article 241 of the same Act. The Rules now set out a method of realization written for crypto-assets. They define a transfer order as an order transferring the claim “in lieu of payment,” and a sale order as an order to sell “in lieu of collection.”
Provisions protecting the debtor apply mutatis mutandis as well. Before issuing a transfer order or a sale order the court must interrogate the debtor, and may dispense with this only where the debtor is abroad or the debtor’s whereabouts are unknown (Article 175-13(1) of the Rules and Article 241(2) of the Civil Execution Act). The court may also have an appraiser value the asset where necessary (Article 175-13(2) of the Rules and Article 163(1) of the Civil Execution Rules).
Transfer order and sale order compared
| Item | Transfer order | Sale order |
|---|---|---|
| Content | The attached right passes to the creditor at a value fixed by the court | An execution officer sells at the market price on the day of sale or another appropriate value (Article 175-6(1)) |
| Effect on the debt | Once final, the debt is treated as satisfied at the time of service in the amount of the value fixed by the court (Article 231 of the Civil Execution Act applied mutatis mutandis) | The proceeds of sale are used for distribution and the rest of the procedure (Article 175-13(1)) |
| Point to watch | No effect if another creditor effects an attachment or provisional attachment, or demands a distribution, before service (Article 229(5) of the Civil Execution Act applied mutatis mutandis) | No sale order is issued if the court finds that nothing would be left after satisfying prior claims and the costs of the procedure (Article 165(1) of the Rules applied mutatis mutandis) |
The amount treated as satisfied under a transfer order is the value fixed by the court. Movements in the market price after the transfer are borne by the creditor, so for a crypto-asset with a volatile price this is worth weighing when choosing between the methods. Falling crypto-asset prices and damages are discussed in Breaching a Coin Payment Agreement in South Korea: Who Bears the Loss From a Price Fall.
By what methods does an execution officer sell crypto-assets?
An execution officer must sell at the market price on the day of sale or another appropriate value, and the Rules set out four methods (Article 175-6(1)).
- Entrusting the sale to the exchange — the sale is entrusted to the exchange, a virtual asset service provider, as garnishee (subparagraph 1). After the sale the exchange hands over to the execution officer what remains of the proceeds after deducting taxes, other public charges and the consignment fee (paragraph (7)).
- Moving the assets to the execution officer’s account and selling — the execution officer opens an account in their own name at that exchange and requests that the attached claim for the transfer of crypto-assets be transferred to that account, and the exchange must comply (subparagraph 2, paragraph (2)).
- Selling through another venue — the exchange is ordered to transfer the crypto-assets to the execution officer, who then sells them through a venue other than the exchange. This includes having them transferred to an execution officer’s account opened with another virtual asset service provider and then selling the claim for their transfer (subparagraph 3).
- Selling after an exchange of assets — the asset is exchanged for other crypto-assets, or claims for their transfer, that are easier to realize, and then sold, or sold through another reasonable procedure (subparagraph 4).
The attachment continues to attach to crypto-assets, or claims for their transfer, that are transferred to the execution officer under subparagraph 2 or 3 (paragraph (3)). On receiving a transfer the execution officer must report to the court without delay the kind and quantity, the crypto-asset address from which the transfer was received and the officer’s account (paragraph (4)). If the execution officer changes after assets have been moved to the officer’s account under subparagraph 2 but before the sale is completed, the successor officer must go through the same steps and the exchange must comply with that request (paragraph (6)).
Which method is to be used is fixed by the court in the sale order (Articles 175-5(1) and 175-6(1)). The suitable method may differ depending on whether the crypto-asset can be sold on an exchange straight away and whether it is traded in sufficient volume, so it helps to explain the trading situation of the particular crypto-asset in the application.
Can crypto-assets held in a private wallet be attached?
There is now a procedure for attaching them. By the attachment order the court prohibits the debtor from disposing of the crypto-assets and orders the debtor to transfer them to an execution officer (Article 175-8(1) and (2)).
Crypto-assets left with an exchange can be tied down by prohibiting the exchange from transferring them, but where the debtor keeps the assets directly there is no third party to whom such an order can be addressed. For that case the amended Rules provide for an order to the debtor to transfer the crypto-assets to an execution officer. On the question of who controls crypto-assets, a Supreme Court decision in a criminal seizure case is instructive. In a case concerning the seizure of Bitcoin in an electronic wallet in the re-appellant’s name that was managed by an exchange, the Supreme Court of Korea held that “a holder of Bitcoin can in this way exercise exclusive de facto control over the management of, or transactions in, the Bitcoin through the private key, and this amounts in the end to substantially controlling the economic value of the Bitcoin” (Supreme Court of Korea, December 11, 2025, 2025Mo45).
Execution of the transfer may be carried out even before the attachment order is served on the debtor, and if the execution officer receives the crypto-assets before service, the attachment takes effect at that point (Article 175-8(3) and (4)). On receiving a transfer the execution officer reports to the court without delay the kind and quantity and the crypto-asset address from which the transfer was received (paragraph (5) of the same Article).
An application for realization may be made after the execution officer has reported to the court that the crypto-assets have been received (Article 175-9(2)). An application for a transfer order must state the creditor’s crypto-asset address, and once the transfer order becomes final the execution officer transfers the crypto-assets to that address (Article 175-10). Under a sale order, the execution officer sells through a virtual asset service provider at the market price on the day of sale or another appropriate value (Article 175-11).
What the amended Rules do not set out in concrete terms, however, is how an execution officer is to receive the crypto-assets where the debtor does not comply with the order to transfer them and does not hand over the private key either, and we have not yet found a judgment dealing with that point. In such a case actual recovery may still be difficult. That is why tying the assets down while they are still at an exchange remains important.
Can a debtor be stopped from moving the assets away before judgment?
They can. The main provisions on the attachment stage apply mutatis mutandis to provisional attachment of crypto-assets and claims for their transfer (Article 213-2) and to a provisional disposition prohibiting the disposal of crypto-assets (Article 216-2).
The provisions applied mutatis mutandis to provisional attachment include Article 175-3, prohibiting the exchange from transferring the assets, Article 175-4 on the exchange’s duty to make a statement, Article 175-8 ordering the debtor to transfer the assets to an execution officer, and Article 175-12 on restoration of the original position on withdrawal or cancellation (Article 213-2). This means that, even before a judgment on the merits, crypto-assets left with an exchange can be stopped from being transferred, and the procedure for having directly held crypto-assets transferred to an execution officer is available as well. The provisions on realization (Articles 175-5 and 175-6, and Articles 175-9 to 175-11) are not on the list applied mutatis mutandis to provisional attachment.
The amended Rules apply to cases that are already pending. An attachment order, a realization order or a preservative measure concerning crypto-assets or a claim for their transfer that was issued before the Rules entered into force is treated as having effect as an order under the amended Rules (Article 2 of the Addenda).
Conversely, where the application for execution is withdrawn or a decision cancelling the compulsory execution procedure takes effect, the execution officer must take steps to restore the original position by transferring the crypto-assets, or the claim for their transfer, back to the original exchange or to the debtor’s side, and must report this to the court. The exchange must then provide the information about the debtor’s account that is needed for the restoration (Article 175-12(1) and (2)).
Frequently asked questions
Q. Do the new rules apply to an attachment order obtained before the amendment?
A. They do. The amended Rules apply to cases pending before a court when they entered into force, and an attachment order, a realization order or a preservative measure concerning crypto-assets or a claim for their transfer that was issued before that date is treated as having effect as an order under the amended Rules (Article 2 of the Addenda to the Civil Execution Rules).
Q. Is a deposit of Korean won held at an exchange attached in the same way?
A. No. These provisions deal with crypto-assets and claims for their transfer. A deposit of Korean won is a right to be repaid money, so it follows the procedure for attachment of monetary claims (Article 223 of the Civil Execution Act) together with a collection order or an assignment order (Article 229 of the same Act). An exchange must, however, deposit or entrust its users’ deposits with a management institution such as a bank, and deposits placed with a management institution in that way may not be attached by anyone, including by provisional attachment (Article 6(1) and (3) of the Act on the Protection of Virtual Asset Users). The approach to consider is therefore to name the exchange, rather than the management institution, as the garnishee, and it is safer to attach the claim for the transfer of crypto-assets at the same time.
Q. Should I apply for a transfer order or a sale order?
A. It depends on the case. A transfer order has the attached claim passed to the creditor at a value fixed by the court, but it has no effect if another creditor effects an attachment or provisional attachment, or demands a distribution, before the order is served (Article 175-13(2) of the Civil Execution Rules and Article 229(5) of the Civil Execution Act). Under a sale order, an execution officer sells the asset and the proceeds are used to carry the procedure forward; the court does not issue a sale order if it finds that nothing would be left after satisfying prior claims and the costs of the procedure (Article 175-13(2) and Article 165(1) of the Civil Execution Rules).
Q. How are crypto-assets that are hard to sell on an exchange realized?
A. The Rules also provide for sale through a venue other than an exchange (Article 175-6(1)3 of the Civil Execution Rules) and for sale after exchanging the asset for other crypto-assets, or claims for their transfer, that are easier to realize (subparagraph 4 of the same paragraph). Which method is to be used is fixed by the court in the sale order.
Q. What happens to crypto-assets already transferred to the execution officer if the application is withdrawn?
A. The execution officer takes steps to restore the original position. The officer transfers the crypto-assets, or the claim for their transfer, back to the original exchange or to the debtor’s side and reports this to the court, and the exchange must provide the information about the debtor’s account that is needed for the restoration (Article 175-12(1) and (2) of the Civil Execution Rules). If the execution officer cannot restore the original position, the court may decide that the asset be sold (paragraph (3) of the same Article).
Q. Is a security right over a claim for the transfer of crypto-assets enforced through this procedure as well?
A. Yes. The new provisions on enforcement against crypto-assets apply mutatis mutandis to the enforcement of a security right over a claim for the transfer of crypto-assets (Article 200-2 of the Civil Execution Rules). The Article listing what must be stated in an application to enforce a security right was amended to include this procedure as well (Article 192 of the same Rules).
Q. What should I do first when preparing enforcement against crypto-assets?
A. Start by identifying which exchange the debtor uses. Applying for a statement by the exchange (Article 175-4 of the Civil Execution Rules) together with the attachment order allows you to confirm whether the exchange holds crypto-assets corresponding to the claim, and of what kind and in what quantity. Before judgment, a provisional attachment (Article 213-2 of the same Rules) can be used to tie the assets down first, and at the realization stage you choose between a transfer order and a sale order according to the case.
This article summarizes the provisions of the Korean Civil Execution Rules in force on November 1, 2026 together with published judgments, and is not legal advice for any particular case. Quotations from Korean judgments and statutes are our English translations. Because the new provisions entered into force only recently, court practice may become more concrete over time. If you are preparing an attachment or a provisional attachment against a debtor who holds crypto-assets, consider consulting Atlas Legal.
